Stupid Charm Squares

I struggled with the Chain Link quilt for a number of reasons. Once was the charm square sizes. Charm squares are supposed to be 5″, right? The charm squares for Chain Link were “about” 5 inches. Some were less and some were more. 

What I do to Charm Squares
What I do to Charm Squares

I try not to buy pre-cuts for this reason, but cutting charms into 2.5 inch squares is a quick way to make 16 patches.

I didn’t wash the Moda Grunge charms I bought recently even though I normally do. I happened to measure the first stack before I started to cut them up. I found they were larger than 5 inches. So I trimmed them, then cut them into 4 pieces. Why can’t charm squares be 5 inches?

I really think that cutting accurately is key. Having charm squares that are touted as being 5 inches NOT be 5 inches is false advertising. It also leads to a lot of problems:

      • designers assume 5 inches and write patterns for 5 inch squares
      • there is an implicit suggestion not to wash the charm squares 
      • starting with an inaccurate size compounds problems across the quilt
      • the above affects a quilt’s outcome and can affect the quiltmaking experience.

I buy fabric to use. If pre-cuts are primarily made to look pretty on a shelf, they should be marketed that way. My advice: cut your own charm squares!